My Choosy Mom chose Jif and now that’s all I Choose

My family was bargain-conscious. Our cart during a food shopping excursion was stacked with generic brands, which according to my Mother, were just as good as the brand labels. She had a few caveats of course, chief among them was her choice in peanut butter. We always bought Jif. When I would question her about why this one non-generic, even when it was so much more expensive, she would simply reply, “because choosy moms choose Jif.”

As an adult, when I go food shopping, peanut butter is a staple and the choice I make was established years ago, I still always buy Jif. Is it the greatest peanut butter? I have no idea, but it is the peanut butter I know. I would like to think that my Mom, in her formative years tasted Jif and shouted “EUREKA!” and that was why we always bought it, but that is probably not true. Instead she, like me, is probably a sucker for a catchphrase and when she tried Jif, she thought, “yeah that is pretty good”, and now because of a good ad campaign, Jif has sold thousands of dollars worth of peanut butter to my family alone.

This Post Has 3 Comments

  1. Drahken

    It’s funny, we were much the same way, buying generic for the majority of things but getting name brand for a few specific things (generic ketchup for example was always utterly vile & just throwing money down the drain. It’s better to SPEND more money than to THROW AWAY less money). However, we always stuck with peter pan peanut butter. We tried jif one time when I was about 8 or 10, I don’t remember much about it except that it had a much stronger -peanut- flavor & that we didn’t like it. After that it was back to peter pan.

  2. Drahken

    Yep, it’s still my first choice, though it’s no longer an exclusive choice. Reese’s peanut butter is about as good (though it has a bit sweeter taste) so I go ahead and grab it if it’s on sale & peter pan isn’t.

Leave a Reply